92K–113K USD / year
Manager of Health Insurance Renewals Team
Customer successHybrid — Denver, CO
Published on 2026-10-22
These details were extracted automatically from the original listing. They may not be complete or fully up to date — it's worth checking the original job post.
About this role
Lead a team of licensed benefits advisors supporting small businesses through health insurance renewals and broader benefits guidance. Drive customer retention and growth while improving the advising experience, team performance, and operational efficiency.
About the company
Gusto is a digital platform that provides payroll, benefits, and human resource management solutions for small to medium-sized businesses. The company focuses on simplifying HR processes and ensuring compliance, while also offering tools for employee engagement and retirement planning.
The team
Health Insurance Benefits Advising team; leads 10–15 licensed advisors and specialists.
What you'll do
- Coach advisors through regular one-on-ones and performance reviews, focusing on expertise, customer experience, and KPIs.
- Meet retention and revenue-growth targets through consultative renewal and upsell strategies.
- Use customer feedback and data to improve processes and advising outcomes.
- Manage large-scale cross-functional initiatives and organizational change.
- Partner with Product, Carrier Operations, Sales, and Customer Experience teams to improve tools, training, and workflows.
- Identify useful AI applications and develop team fluency while protecting compliance and customer trust.
What we're looking for
- 4–6 years of formal leadership experience in benefits advising, customer success, renewals, or a similar field.
- Direct experience with small-group health insurance, including fully insured, level-funded, or PEO models.
- Demonstrated ability to grow revenue, retain customers, and expand accounts through consultative renewals.
- Strong analytical, operational, process-improvement, and cross-functional leadership skills.
- Experience with technology or automation solutions such as Salesforce, APIs, and benefits administration platforms.
- Ability to evaluate AI tools with attention to productivity, efficiency, risk, compliance, and customer trust.
- Life & Health insurance license, or willingness to obtain one.
- Comfort leading teams through rapid change in a fast-paced environment.
Nice to have
- Experience with ancillary coverage, tax-advantaged accounts, or 401(k) plans.
Benefits
- Equity in the form of RSUs
